When I was in Kindergarten, my
favorite teacher was Sister Vincent, the Music and Motion instructor. She gave the best hugs – which I really
needed in Kindergarten because I had no idea what was going on most of the
time, and that can be scary when you’re six.
Sister Vincent and I became pals, and soon I declared my intention to be
a nun. This got a lot more attention
than I had expected, so I kept saying it, and saying it, and saying it, and
eventually it became true. I visited
lots of convents as a pre-teen. My
parents were thrilled. By the time I was
12, I was pretty bored by my sheltered life as a home school kid with no
extra-curricular activities. I was ready
to go out and slay the world.
And that’s when I met the
Consecrated. Pairs of them came to visit
us every few months. They gave me lots
of attention and told me wonderful stories about the life of a Precandidate – a
girl who renounced the world and joined a band of sisters to discern a vocation
and be trained in the ways of God, a girl who gave her heart to Jesus so he
could mold her into his instrument. The picture
they painted was irresistible. I had to go. I attended a couple camps and retreats, and I
was always treated like a VIP, and given special jobs and special time with the
consecrated. By the time I was old
enough for the Summer Program, wild horses couldn’t have kept me out of the
PC. I was 14 when I arrived in RI – 3,000
miles away from my home and my family.
I knew from the start that I was staying for the year, for
all the years of highschool and then I was going to get consecrated. Why else leave my family? And my family seemed a lot less boring now
that I was so far away. I cried myself
to sleep every night for months and months.
I especially missed my little sister, who had always been at my
side. I was constantly turning around to
make a joke or criticize someone’s clothes and finding an empty spot where she
should have been.
Despite my homesickness, the first
few months were easy. I knew I was doing
the right thing, and the Consecrated were so nice to all of us, and the other
girls were so much fun. The rules were
hard, but it wasn’t the end of the world if you didn’t follow them
perfectly. Then things began to
change. The Consecrated weren’t so
tolerant of chatting in the hallways.
They started insisting that I walk and sit and talk “like a lady.” My human formator started hassling me about
waxing my facial hair and losing the five pounds I’d gained that summer. First it was once a week, then it was once a
day, then I started hiding in closets when I’d see her, because every time she’d
lay eyes on me she’d want “a little talk.”
Eventually I broke down and did what she wanted.
I started to feel really lonely. We had less and less free time, until finally, free time was the time you spent brushing your teeth, using the toilet and walking to and from meals and activities. The time we did get to spend working and playing together with our friends was precious. We had sports every day, which I hated. I’m a complete clutz and I’m 5’2” on a tall day. 30 minutes of basketball every day was 30 minutes of Chinese torture. But it was basketball or nothing, so I’d pick an unobtrusive part of the court and try to stay out of everyone’s way. I had no exercise outside of walking to activities. When we had an outing on Saturday it was like Christmas. We could sing whenever we wanted, we could run, we could talk to each other. It was always so depressing to come home and put on nylons again and go to the chapel.
I started to feel really lonely. We had less and less free time, until finally, free time was the time you spent brushing your teeth, using the toilet and walking to and from meals and activities. The time we did get to spend working and playing together with our friends was precious. We had sports every day, which I hated. I’m a complete clutz and I’m 5’2” on a tall day. 30 minutes of basketball every day was 30 minutes of Chinese torture. But it was basketball or nothing, so I’d pick an unobtrusive part of the court and try to stay out of everyone’s way. I had no exercise outside of walking to activities. When we had an outing on Saturday it was like Christmas. We could sing whenever we wanted, we could run, we could talk to each other. It was always so depressing to come home and put on nylons again and go to the chapel.
Oh, how I hated the chapel! We
were always supposed to begin with a “balance,” an examination of
conscience. We all had little books we
were supposed to use to write down our sins, and we all had a program (I think
that’s what we called it), that spelled out our biggest failing and all the
little failings that fell under it. Every year when I made mine, my spiritual
director helped me see that I was overflowing with pride. I knew I was proud and independent and a
little cynical, but it was hard for me to see my natural personality as a
character flaw. So every day, several
times a day, I would kneel in the chapel and look at my outline of sins and try
to figure out how to do better when better seemed if not worse, at least
unnatural. It was unbelievably
depressing. Not only was I lonely, I
wasn’t good enough, by nature.
But my relationship with Mary and
with Jesus in the Eucharist was supposed to make up for my loneliness and my
depression. So I put all my energy into
trying to get the love and friendship I needed from voices in my head.
I’m relating all of this as if I came up with it on my own, but I didn’t. We had “directed meditation,” in which consecrated would think out loud for us while we knelt in the chapel, we listened to countless formal talks, Gospel something or other where we would read from the letters of the Founder and listen to the consecrateds’ thoughts about the passage, spiritual reading, where we’d read an assigned religious volume, spiritual direction every week, and “little chats” with a consecrated who was in charge of my studies, one who was in charge of making me look like a proper little consecrated, and one other who I think was supposed to help me be better at recruiting other girls to the PC… it’s been so many years, it’s hard to remember every detail. My point is, these ideas did not spring from my own fertile imagination. They were carefully placed there.
The pressure built and built and built. The more years I was there, the more panicked I became that I wouldn’t make the cut for consecrated. I needed to get with the program and conform if I wanted to fulfill God’s will for me. So I tried harder and harder. I gave up my thoughts and desires, I knuckled under and shut up and quit asking uncomfortable questions. I was silent during silence, and I never said inappropriate things when we were allowed to talk (that’s the one that really killed me). I spent more time in the chapel. I was the last to leave the chapel for breakfast, I rushed faster and faster through my morning and evening prep so I could have a few extra minutes there. I stood in front of the statue or picture of Mary as long as I was allowed, trying so hard to feel what I knew I should feel.
I’m relating all of this as if I came up with it on my own, but I didn’t. We had “directed meditation,” in which consecrated would think out loud for us while we knelt in the chapel, we listened to countless formal talks, Gospel something or other where we would read from the letters of the Founder and listen to the consecrateds’ thoughts about the passage, spiritual reading, where we’d read an assigned religious volume, spiritual direction every week, and “little chats” with a consecrated who was in charge of my studies, one who was in charge of making me look like a proper little consecrated, and one other who I think was supposed to help me be better at recruiting other girls to the PC… it’s been so many years, it’s hard to remember every detail. My point is, these ideas did not spring from my own fertile imagination. They were carefully placed there.
The pressure built and built and built. The more years I was there, the more panicked I became that I wouldn’t make the cut for consecrated. I needed to get with the program and conform if I wanted to fulfill God’s will for me. So I tried harder and harder. I gave up my thoughts and desires, I knuckled under and shut up and quit asking uncomfortable questions. I was silent during silence, and I never said inappropriate things when we were allowed to talk (that’s the one that really killed me). I spent more time in the chapel. I was the last to leave the chapel for breakfast, I rushed faster and faster through my morning and evening prep so I could have a few extra minutes there. I stood in front of the statue or picture of Mary as long as I was allowed, trying so hard to feel what I knew I should feel.
And I got migraines. It started with just a few, then they
multiplied and got more and more severe.
I didn’t know what they were, and they scared the crap out of me. I thought I had a brain tumor. I was sure I was dying. They literally paralyzed me, gave me intense
panic attacks, I saw lights and heard voices, I would get facial ticks, and the
pain was so bad at times that I couldn’t help but yell and cry, even during
almighty Absolute Silence. My spiritual
director advised me not to tell my parents since we were both sure they’d fly
me home immediately. The migraines went
on for 6 months before I finally asked my mom for help. In all that time, no one rushed me to the ER when I would daily collapse in the hallway or slump over at my desk or in my pew. No one called my parents, no one offered to schedule a doctor appointment for me. No one called my parents. I was 16.
My parents arranged for me to see a doctor in RI, and at one point I remember going to the ER. The doctors didn’t seem to know what was wrong, and of course I didn’t really tell them my symptoms because I didn’t want to be a whiner. I figured the tests would show I had cancer and we’d go from there. Since I hadn't told my parents the pain I had been in for so many months, I was reluctant to tell them how bad it was. I said I was having these episodes occasionally, and I wasn't sure what they were. My mom was fairly certain they were migraines, and gave me some tips for alleviating and avoiding them. I waited a couple more months, still suffering daily, debilitating migraines, but at least feeling somewhat comforted that I probably didn't have a malignant tumor. They continued to increase in intensity and frequency, until my right foot was difficult to lift when I walked to the showers in the morning. It was decided that I should go home for a cat scan since the insurance would cover it in CA, and so I left the PC, promising I would be back in a few weeks. The day I came home, I stayed in bed to recover from the trip and the raging migraine. The next day I had a headache, but no other symptoms. The severe and constant migraines of the Precandidacy were apparently only a PC phenomenon, because while I had headaches at home, I only had the massive attacks while under great stress - for instance, immediately after fighting with my parents, who wanted me to stay home from the Precandidacy for good. At home, I had a few tests and a few doctor visits, and it was determined that I had serial migraines, though no one suggested tchey could be stress-related.
My parents arranged for me to see a doctor in RI, and at one point I remember going to the ER. The doctors didn’t seem to know what was wrong, and of course I didn’t really tell them my symptoms because I didn’t want to be a whiner. I figured the tests would show I had cancer and we’d go from there. Since I hadn't told my parents the pain I had been in for so many months, I was reluctant to tell them how bad it was. I said I was having these episodes occasionally, and I wasn't sure what they were. My mom was fairly certain they were migraines, and gave me some tips for alleviating and avoiding them. I waited a couple more months, still suffering daily, debilitating migraines, but at least feeling somewhat comforted that I probably didn't have a malignant tumor. They continued to increase in intensity and frequency, until my right foot was difficult to lift when I walked to the showers in the morning. It was decided that I should go home for a cat scan since the insurance would cover it in CA, and so I left the PC, promising I would be back in a few weeks. The day I came home, I stayed in bed to recover from the trip and the raging migraine. The next day I had a headache, but no other symptoms. The severe and constant migraines of the Precandidacy were apparently only a PC phenomenon, because while I had headaches at home, I only had the massive attacks while under great stress - for instance, immediately after fighting with my parents, who wanted me to stay home from the Precandidacy for good. At home, I had a few tests and a few doctor visits, and it was determined that I had serial migraines, though no one suggested tchey could be stress-related.
I eventually persuaded my reluctant parents (with full support of the consecrated, who were calling me at least once a week, and making sure I got a constant stream of letters from my favorite PC's), and back I went. The migraines
started again the first day at the Precandidacy. They
got worse and worse until I couldn’t participate in any activities at all. I finally broke the news to my parents after several more months of misery, and
came home again six months before graduation.
That broke my heart. I figured
that I would grow out of the migraines at some point and be able to return and
get consecrated, but Fr. Bannon wrote me a letter a few months after I left and
told me it was unlikely I had a vocation.
That was news to me. I figured he
was too busy to bother with me, and I still intended to get well and go
back.
The rest is a story for another
day.
I bet if you were actually able to confide in your friends you never would have gotten the migraines at all. I'm so sorry you had to go through that physical suffering and mostly alone. We were all very concerned for you and missed you when you left. I agree that they seemed to want us all to fit into one mold. I used to get terrible stomach pains everytime I was forced so far outside of my comfort zone and away from my personality type. Guiding Eucharistic Hours, Morning meditations, any form of public speaking and I was in need of my new best friend, Pepcid. Eventually it became too much for me too, four monthes into the consecrated life in Mexico, where they pushed even harder for me to do what I didn't feel I was capable of (and I hardly understood the language thanks to not taking spanish class seriously) I experienced my own nervous breakdown and FINALLY convinced Mary Carmen to contact my parents and discuss my coming home. Everyone has their limitations and as much as I was willing to follow in the saints' and martyrs' footsteps I couldn't do good for anyone anymore. I felt I had failed and I was angry with God for taking my trust and throwing me into a situation I was fully uncomfortable with. But despite my anger I have come to understand how much good can still come out of a difficult experience. I found my true vocation and have no doubt in it whatsoever. I love my vocation to be a wife and mother and feel I wouldn't be so confident if I hadn't come from where I was.
ReplyDeleteIt's hard to imagine a situation where the Precandidacy would have worked and we would have been able to confide in each other. Can you imagine having 80 teenage girls living together without putting them in straight jackets? We would have been wild. No, I think the PC was/is irrefutably flawed in its most basic principle. A 14-year-old is not in any position to seriously discern a vocation. Teenagers should be finding out who they are, not choosing a career.
ReplyDeleteI'm so sorry you had to feel that pain too. Even worse than the physical pain is the emotional trauma of failing to live up to what you have been convinced is God's plan for you. That was a bitter time for me.
This is very well written. Thank you for sharing, Megan. It's so strange hearing this perspective now because I was always so envious of your apparent inward peace. I am looking forward to "another" day.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Mary. That was one of the creepier aspects of the PC - so many of us were in turmoil and the more wildly out of control we were on the inside, the more phony plastic peace we displayed to everyone else. I know you experienced that too. If you ever feel that it would help, I'd love to hear your story.
Delete